Why do four ideal weight formulas give different results?
Because each one was fitted in a different decade and population sample (Hamwi in 1964, Devine in 1974, Robinson and Miller in 1983), with its own coefficient per inch of height above 1.52 m; there is no fifth formula that arbitrates between them, which is why the result is usually shown as a range.
Is reference weight a weight-loss target?
That is not their origin: these formulas were built for clinical use, mainly to calculate medication dosing by body weight, not as an aesthetic or weight-loss goal. The number is a reference convention, and any individual weight target is a decision for a health professional.
Which formula is used to calculate medication dosing by weight?
The Devine formula, published in 1974, is the one most cited in clinical pharmacology to estimate the body weight used for dosing calculations of certain medications, a use distinct from any personal weight goal.
Do reference weight formulas work for people of short stature?
Below 1.52 m, not proportionally: the height term in all four formulas locks at zero at that point, so any shorter height receives the same base weight with no differentiation, which shows they were calibrated for adult heights at or above 1.52 m.